0.jpg
1 / 45

217 Old Toll, Lake Arrowhead, CA 92352

$725K3bd · 3ba · 1,600 sqft
Lot 11,150 sqft•Single Family Residence•
Active
•51d on market•MLS# IG-26184258

Property Description

Design forward, extensively updated and set against one of Lake Arrowhead’s most compelling ridgeline views, The Tollhouse is a modern mountain classic, beautifully reimagined without losing its original character. With lake rights, level parking for three vehicles and two expansive decks, this three story retreat is made for effortless mountain living. Soaring wood clad ceilings, exposed beams and a dramatic wall of glass define the main living space, while an impressive stone fireplace brings warmth and mountain character. The completely remodeled kitchen features soft white cabinetry, stone countertops, floating wood shelving and warm gold details. New sliding glass doors open the living room to the deck and sweeping ridgeline beyond, where fog rolls through the treetops below. The king primary suite is conveniently located on the main level with a fully remodeled en suite bath and statement shower featuring designer tilework. Upstairs, a queen bedroom, generous bunk room, loft and 3/4 bath provide plenty of space for family and guests. Downstairs, an expansive game room with bar and its own deck offers incredible flexibility for entertaining, a second living space or additional guest suite. A half bath and dedicated laundry room with new washer and dryer complete the level. Recent improvements include new central air conditioning, three new mini splits, recessed lighting in the kitchen and game room, and resealed windows. Outside, mornings begin with miles of forest and evenings are made for roasting marshmallows around the fire as the sun fades behind the ridgeline and fog drifts through the trees. Offered fully furnished, The Tollhouse boasts an impeccable short term rental history and consistent five star guest ratings, equally suited as a private Lake Arrowhead retreat, full time residence or proven hospitality offering.

Features & Amenities

FeeBuilt 1978

Property Details

Land Type
Fee
Year Built
1978
Property Type
Residential
Property Subtype
Single Family Residence
Parking Spaces
3
Garage Spaces
0
Heating
Central
Cooling
Central Air, Zoned, See Remarks
View
Mountain(s), Trees/Woods
Flooring
Wood
City
Lake Arrowhead
Zip Code
92352
County
San Bernardino
Listed byUnknown Office, Christen Sheridan

Mortgage Calculator

Current Rates

$
$
%
Monthly Payment
$3,665.99
Principal & Interest
Loan Amount
$580,000
Total Interest
$739,758
Total Payment Over 30 Years
$1,319,758
This calculator provides estimates only. Actual mortgage payments may include taxes, insurance, HOA fees, and PMI. Contact a lender for accurate quotes.

Comparative Market Analysis

Residential Tier · 5 active · 5 closed

217 Old Toll, Lake Arrowhead, CA 92352

Lake Arrowhead · Single Family Residence

$725K
Residential Tier
Beds
3
Baths
3
Sqft
1,600
Lot
11,150 sqft
Year
1978
$/Sqft
$453
Pool: No✓
Spa: No✓
View: mountain✓

Listed 54.3% above the median closed sale of $470,000. Price per sqft ($453) is a 39% premium to closed comps ($326). Expect a longer timeline — comps averaged 131 days on market.

Price Position

Positioned above the market — commands a premium.

Premium
Subject listed at $725K· $453/sqft
Total list price
Closed comps
vs closed median $470K
+$255K (+54.3%)
Active comps
vs active median $525K
+$200K (+38.1%)
Price per sqft
Closed compsinsufficient comp data
Active comps
vs active avg $/sqft $409
+$44 (+10.6%)

Active Properties (5)

Active Comparables

AddressCityYearBDBTHSqFtLotSzLP/SqFtLPDIMScore
401 Grass ValleyLake Arrowhead1979321,3009,400$346$450,0001189
26525 Walnut HillsLake Arrowhead1982321,20010,512$371$445,0002488
27809 North BayLake Arrowhead1972321,26013,420$452$569,00010685
1208 AleutianLake Arrowhead1992321,2208,690$430$525,0005983
1170 KlondikeLake Arrowhead1974321,2257,800$448$549,00013782
Total: 5 · Average3.02.01,2419,964.4$409.4$507,60067.4
Median1,225$525,000

Closed Properties (5)

Closed Comparables

AddressCityYearDateBDBTHSqFtLotSzLPSPSP/SqFtSP/LPDIMScore
1285 Yukon DriveLake Arrowhead199209/25/2026331,39710,100$475,000$470,000$3360.9913291
460 Pioneer RoadLake Arrowhead197709/22/2026331,8568,450$499,999$475,000$2560.9518690
1341 Calgary DriveLake Arrowhead197509/14/2026321,2049,750$425,000$395,000$3280.9310387
175 MassiveLake Arrowhead198409/29/2026321,61410,500$440,000$430,000$2660.9818385
118 E LaneLake Arrowhead195509/25/2026321,37212,800$610,000$610,000$4451.005183
Total: 5 · Average3.02.41,488.610,320$476,000$476,000$326.2—131
Median1,397$470,000$470,000

Market Analysis

List vs Sale $/SqFt

Sale Price Trend

Days on Market

Sale vs List Price

AI-generated CMA

This analysis was generated automatically from MLS data. For an in-depth, human-reviewed valuation, contact Joseph Sardella at josephsardella@gmail.com.